27 August 2010 3 Comments

We Need a National Commuting Ban

Every time I am stuck in snarled stop-and-go traffic I am reminded of the same thing: it shouldn’t be this way.

The unstoppable march of technology has made it possible for the vast majority of the people sitting in their cars, parked on the freeway sipping their latte to do the exact same job without going to the office. Between video conferencing, collaboration tools, wikis, email, Skype the “office” is an obsolete relic.

The advantages to reducing commuting to those people who must necessarily commute to perform their job would be tremendous.

1) Fewer cars on the road, everyone would get to their destination more quickly. Less time stuck in traffic = enormous increase in work output. This would be instantly reflected in the GDP.

2) Fewer cars leaving their garages would mean more cars available for car-sharing programs like Relay Rides. Suddenly, the household with 3 cars (1 for mom, 1 for dad, 1 for the high school junior) only needs 1 or 2 cars at most. And one of them can be shared out to someone who can give up their car completely.

3) There is a a growing mountain of evidence that commuting is measurably bad for your health. Nearly 50% of Americans commute. Call it 120million people. If even 20% of them (it seems likely that a much, much higher percentage of commuting is unnecessary) would stop commuting, you’d instantly make almost 30 million Americans more healthy.

4) Consider the ancillary benefits of people not spending 2 hours a day in their car. Less time in the car, fewer stops at Burger King for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. More time at home to cook good meals for themselves and their families. Finally that extra hour in the day to get a quick workout in. Or another hour to spend with the kids. In some families it might be the only hour they get with their children.

What are the downsides? There aren’t any.

If you like what’s here, please follow me on twitter here.

3 Responses to “We Need a National Commuting Ban”

  1. Joe 27 August 2010 at 10:58 pm #

    I’ve thought the same thing for a while now, and I agree completely. At a minimum, we should try and move people more to some form of mass transit. People might cry at first that they have to walk a little, but it would also be better for the nations health.

  2. Joe 27 August 2010 at 11:01 pm #

    I should specify though that I don’t think I would be for any kind of outright ban though.

  3. Jon 28 August 2010 at 9:33 am #

    Working virtually would solve a big slice of the problem, but to take it to another level, city planning is a huge culprit as well. The design of cities based on a city center with a ring of more and more distant suburbs is a terrible layout for many reasons.

    There is a great website that scores the “walkability” of neigborhoods: http://www.walkscore.com/rankings/ Living in a walkable hood allows you to go to work and exercise at the same time.